Shrink that link
One of my students asked if he could use Twitter-style URLs when referencing web sources in his dissertation.
These URLs are generated by Twitter apps or stand-alone web sites which translate full URLs into a much shorter version.
This version will expand back into the full URL and point to the correct source when clicked.
How does it work?
Copy your URL
go to (e.g.) http://bit.ly/
paste the URL in the ‘shorten field, and click Shorten.
Then copy and paste the new URL into the footnote or bibliography.
Result?
Compare this full URL:
http://ftalphaville.ft.com/blog/2009/10/06/75836/the-world-and-the-dollar-reacts-to-robert-fisk/?source=rss
to the shortened version from bit.ly
http://bit.ly/3QHp23.
Problem solved …
The new URL is much more usable. Standard URLs are long, ugly, and difficult to use, especially if you’re working from a hard copy.
I said this student could use these URLs, and wondered if it might be something we could incorporate into our academic style guide
… or not
But there are problems:
How long do these shrink-wrapped links last?
What happens if the sites offering these services die off?
And these problems got me thinking (after a chat to Paul Stainthorp) about other web-related referencing issues:
What happens if the site archives the source and the URL changes?
what happens if a student links to a source that ends up behind a pay-wall?
(E.g., the Economist currently allows free online access to copy published in the last 12 months – but from 13 October, non-subscribers can only see copy under 90 days old.)
I’ve touched on just two, but there must be plenty of others related to copyright issues, deep-linking, database sources, e-journals?
I’m not sure where this should go. (Do we have some kind of academic standards committee?) But I am sure we need to start thinking about it. I’d certainly welcome some guidance.
One of my students asked if he could use Twitter-style URLs when referencing web sources in his dissertation.
These URLs are generated by Twitter apps or stand-alone web sites which translate full URLs into a much shorter version.
This version will expand back into the full URL and point to the correct source when clicked.
How does it work?
- Copy your URL
- Co to (e.g.) http://bit.ly/
- Paste the URL in the ‘shorten’ field, and click Shorten.
- Then copy and paste the new URL into the footnote or bibliography.
Result?
Compare this full URL:
http://ftalphaville.ft.com/blog/2009/10/06/75836/the-world-and-the-dollar-reacts-to-robert-fisk/?source=rss
to the shortened version from bit.ly
http://bit.ly/3QHp23
User-friendly
Standard URLs are long, ugly, and difficult to use, especially if you’re working from a hard copy. The new URL is much more usable.
I said this student could use these URLs, and wondered if it might be something we could/should incorporate into our academic style guide?
Problems?
But there are problems:
- How long do these shrink-wrapped links last?
- What happens if the sites offering these services die off?
And these problems got me thinking (after a chat to Paul Stainthorp) about other web-related referencing issues:
- What happens if the site archives the source and the URL changes?
- What happens if a student links to a source that ends up behind a pay-wall? (E.g., The Economist currently allows free online access to copy published in the last 12 months – but from 13 October, non-subscribers can only see copy under 90 days old.)
I’ve touched on just two, but there must be plenty of others related to copyright issues, deep-linking, database sources, e-journals?
I’m not sure where to go with this. (Do we have some kind of academic standards committee?) But I am sure we need to start thinking about it. I’d certainly welcome some guidance.